Jeremy Todd was a two-time all-American for the Trevecca baseball team while playing for the Trojans from 1999-01. In his two-year career Todd set several Trevecca hitting records including the single season home run record and was second on the career home run list. As a senior Todd was the TranSouth Conference Player of the Year, NAIA all-American, All-Region XI, and All-TranSouth. Todd Maintains a top ten ranking in five career categories:  first in batting average (.471), third in home runs (33), tied for seventh in doubles (33), ninth in RBI (108), and tenth in runs scored (120). Todd also Maintains the record for season batting average (.534) and season runs scored (74). Todd tied an NAIA record by hitting four home runs in a single game in consecutive at bats.

Jeremy just completed his sixth professional season and his first with the Lancaster Barnstormers of the Atlantic Baseball League. While playing for Lancaster Barnstormers manager Tommy Herr, Todd was chosen by Atlantic League as members of the 2005 All-Star team. Todd, acquired in a July 4 trade with Newark, was named as the designated hitter on the squad. The Pismo Beach, CA resident ended the year with 107 runs batted in, second only to Nashua's Brian Becker. He led the Atlantic League with 39 doubles, and finished in the top five in total bases, slugging percentage, on-base percentage and extra-base hits. With Lancaster alone, he hit 19 homers and 69 RBI in 77 games.

Originally signed as a non-drafted free agent by the New York Mets in 2000, Jeremy spent two seasons in the Mets chain and part of one season in the Colorado Rockies organization. In 2002, while playing with Yuma in the Western League, Jeremy batted .309 and produced a career-best 20 doubles. The following season he batted .322 in 47 games for Jackson in the Central League. Last season with Amarillo he was named the CBL Rawlings Player of the Month.